State Review Finds Gaps in Oversight at Kilby Prison

Examiners subpoenaed ADOC records and found just three prosecutor referrals in 96 sexual assault investigation files

Share
State Review Finds Gaps in Oversight at Kilby Prison
Image — Special Review cover page

TL;DR — A State review of Kilby Correctional Facility found gaps in how Alabama tracks officer discipline and refers sexual assault cases to prosecutors. The pilot review also flagged poor conditions at Kilby and barriers to oversight at ADOC headquarters.

State examiners found just three documented referrals to prosecutors in 96 sexual assault investigation files from Kilby Correctional Facility. They also found that a missing disciplinary record helped an officer avoid a recommendation for dismissal after a second excessive-force offense within three years.

The Alabama Department of Examiners of Public Accounts filed the 367-page review Nov. 6. Examiners began with Kilby, a prison in Mount Meigs that receives and classifies men entering State custody. They expanded their work to include parts of the Alabama Department of Corrections central office after tracing some problems to department-wide practices. The review ran from May through October as part of a pilot program to help lawmakers decide on extending independent reviews to other State prisons.

Getting some of the records involved in the review required a subpoena. Examiners said ADOC routed their requests through its Legal Division and required a legal representative to be present for access to most employees. ABC 33/40’s I-Team reported that Chief Examiner Rachel Laurie Riddle raised the records problem with lawmakers in July, before her office had publicly named the prison.

Examiners reviewed 96 sexual assault investigation files covering incidents from October 2023 through September 2025. Three showed referrals to prosecutors. One file gave no indication either way. ADOC rules require investigators to refer criminal cases to the appropriate prosecutor. Examiners urged the department to leave charging decisions to prosecutors.

Investigators could supply no files for seven other reported incidents, including an allegation against a staff member. In a sample of cases, examiners found that investigators had retained no video evidence in 64% of the files.

The review also found that 26% of disciplinary actions in a sample of Kilby personnel files were missing from ADOC’s electronic discipline system. One officer’s three-day suspension for excessive force in 2023 was among the missing entries. After a second incident in March 2025, a 10-day suspension was recommended and later cut to one day. Examiners said the department’s guidelines called for a recommendation to dismiss the officer.

An Aug. 18 inspection documented malfunctioning toilets and showers, mold and mildew, and noticeably hot housing units. The review also flagged a concern that reached beyond Kilby. Staff told examiners at least 100 ADOC employees had access to license plate reader data, and the department could identify no specific policy governing its use. Examiners urged ADOC to review who has access and require users to record why they look up data.

In its written response included with the review, ADOC said it provided access to more than 20,000 digital files and 32 boxes of records. The department cautioned against drawing conclusions about staff actions solely from missing paperwork. Commissioner Greg Lovelace directed agency leaders to review the findings and make changes where warranted.

ADOC said major repairs would require funding from lawmakers. It also pointed to the State’s plan to close Kilby as replacement beds become available.

The U.S. Justice Department sued Alabama and its Department of Corrections in December 2020, four years after opening an investigation into the State’s prisons for men. Federal investigators warned Alabama in April 2019 that men in its prisons faced a serious risk of being killed, beaten or sexually assaulted by other prisoners. A second report, issued in July 2020, found evidence that prison staff routinely used excessive force. Federal officials said overcrowding and severe staffing shortages made conditions worse.

The lawsuit alleges that Alabama knew about those risks and failed to address them, violating the Eighth Amendment’s ban on cruel and unusual punishment. The Justice Department asked the court to order the State to correct the conditions. ADOC disputed the allegations when the suit was filed. The agency acknowledged that staff may have failed to follow procedures in some cases, but argued that federal officials portrayed isolated incidents as a pattern across the prison system.

The Alabama Reflector reported that the trial is set to begin Nov. 30, 2026. At an Oct. 30 hearing in Huntsville, U.S. District Judge Harold Mooty III said he expected the trial could take six weeks and had set aside eight, according to Alabama Appleseed. The Kilby review brings some of the same issues back before State lawmakers, including how ADOC tracks excessive force and what happens after someone reports a sexual assault.

The prison system also drew national attention in October 2025 when HBO aired The Alabama Solution. Filmmakers Andrew Jarecki and Charlotte Kaufman used footage shot by incarcerated men on contraband cellphones to examine reports of abuse and a death in custody.

The Kilby report went to legislative leaders and the Joint Prison Oversight Committee. Its recommendations are only advisory. Ultimately, lawmakers will have to decide whether to extend the pilot to other prisons — and just what action(s) to take on those recommendations.

The full Special Review is attached: